Udayar and pillars of the Earth
  • Dear all

    Has anyone read Pillars of the earth by Ken Follet? Was it the inspirartion behind Balakumarans Udayar?

    Sri
  • I read first two parts of udayar.Did not read the remaining
    parts.But I dont think POE and Udayar are related.Except the theme
    to build a church/temple they are no way related.The hero in udayar
    is a king.In POE it is Tom builder,his son and a monk(forgot his
    name).

    I dont think they are same.
  • dear all


    i think udayar has very little inspiraton behind it.let alone p o e
    its just a samooka novel in a historical background.
    ken follet's pillars of the earth is one great book with enormous
    details about the period.
    right from architecture to politics.
    very rarely has follet eached its excellence after that.
    if balakumaran had read pillars of the earth deinitely he would have
    done a better job.
  • Dear Samptah,venkat and SPS

    Havent read Pillars of earth will strive to...was put off by its size before my Prefinal exams

    I have successfully completed the fourth part of Udayar...Has anyone read the fifth???

    Nothing more to add after the second part venkat...because at the end of fourth part the temple still stands with foundation and as replica...



    There were two things I learnt from the book..

    The circumferntial saram with reinforced mud...Old members may remember Dr Jaybee saking about this and there were graphic descriptions by our freinds..

    Second thing is
    The Gopuram itself is a lingam agasalingam....the Interior hollow of the gopuram is another lingam...Arubalingam and then the Deity itself...

    That was nice...

    But a lot of wasted pages like venkat sad it is a social novel in historic setting
  • Dear sri,
    ken follet is one hell of a writer. pity we dont have many such
    people in our vicinity.
    and pillars of the earth was a really descriptive novel of a society
    in medival england around the murder of archbishop of canterbury,
    with the construction of the cathedral in the background.
    talks about england france and the moors in spain.
    1000 pages i think and i wouldnt mind reading it again.
    perhaps its the second longest book i have read after ps.
    those who can lay their hands on pillars of the earth please do read
    it.
  • vanakkam,

    Doctor, the fifth part of udayar hasn't yet been published. I believe
    he has already written it in serial form in a monthly pocket novel.
    Trying to get it.

    It is way too long, needs a lot of editing. Esp, the fourth part is
    more of a social novel. I doubt whether there was such an unrest in
    that period.

    The book is like a curate's egg - good in parts. There are some parts
    in the book that are too good. Remember the elephant chasing Rajendra?

    Pillars of Earth is a good book, but pretty long. One needs to read it
    patiently. I liked that prior's characterization very much. It is
    definitely worth reading once.

    swetha

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Top Posters