kalki's film review
  • http://www.hindu.com/cp/2008/02/08/stories/2008020850351600.htm

    hi venkat, why did kalki tear this film to pieces as described above..

    vj
  • >
    > Dear Venkat,
    >
    > Rondar Guy's MADRAS MUSICNGs in MYLAPORE TIMES ..
    >
    > any one having the collections ??
    >
    > thanks Vijay. sps
    >
    the famous murders...wow, if someone can get the two famous madras
    murders....

    coming to think of it,here is a bio of the great mkt

    http://raja1630.tripod.com/mktb/id1.html
  • Hi

    Here are 3 of the articles

    http://www.hinduonnet.com/thehindu/mp/2002/03/25/stories/
    2002032500190300.htm


    http://www.appusami.com/HTML/htmlv113/main/ALAVANDAR.asp



    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N._S._Krishnan

    there is a small connection to the kalki group . the clue is hidden
    in the wikipedia article on ns krishnan- link given above.
  • Hi
    Kalki was harsh on most movies.
    he reportedly gave auvaiyar only a good chit.
    but as the saying goes, people who live in glasshouses should not
    throw stones..
    thats what happened to kalki.
    all his movies were torn to pieces by the press which was waiting for
    its turn.
    imagine what would happen if subbudu performed a kutcheri.
    kalki was particularly harsh on p.u chinnappa.
    on kittappa i dont know. even in this particular review i dont know
    his views on k.B. S.
    will check out.

    venketesh
  • THAT IS A LOVELY LINK..
    THANK YOU VIJAY...

    Pudukkottai Dakshinamurthy
    Veenai Dhanammal
    Maharajapuram Viswanatha Iyer
    Thiruvavaduthurai Rajarathnam Pillai
    Konnakkol Paakkirisami
    .... some of the All Time Greats of Yester Years !!!!!!

    Not to speak of MK Thiagaraja Bagavathar!

    In Chennai, T Nagar, Pondy Bazaar, (formerly) Rajakumari theatre (-
    which belonged to her once. Janapriya shopping complex) is near
    Thanikachalam street, on which MKT's bunglow was situated.

    Film Financier Lena Chettiar's bunglow was just across the road
    (near Hindi Prachar Sabha !)


    Superstition was that : " Appanaippaadum vaayaal suppanai
    paaduveno ?" caused MKT downward trend.

    sps
  • Dear Venkat,

    lovely link on MKT and NSK..

    Reminds me to add:

    The road abutting Rajakumari theatre on the Southern side is
    LAKSHMI KANTHAN ROAD ! (irony ?!)

    sps
  • I have heard somewhere that Kalki thought the acting in Nandanar was dreadful.. he is supposed to have said that even animals can act better ! (he is definitely capable of being acerbic!) His Carnatic music reviews (which he wrote under a pen name "Karnatakan") tended to be harsh, but with humor and sarcasm.. there is a collection of his music reviews published, but I haven't been able to find it.




    Posted by: "Vijay Kumar .S" vj.episteme@gmail.com vj_episteme
    Sun Feb 10, 2008 10:22 pm (PST)
    http://www.hindu. com/cp/2008/ 02/08/stories/ 2008020850351600 .htm

    hi venkat, why did kalki tear this film to pieces as described above..

    vj
  • Regretfully, Nandanar failed at the box office and `Kalki' in a
    famous review in Ananda Vikatan tore it to pieces


    Hi
    randor guy otherwise a good researcher made one mistake
    kalki had left ananda vikadan in 1941 and the movie was made by vasan.
    the review came in kalki magazine( not known for its unbiased views-
    in fact the first and most complimentary film review ever published
    was about majority stake holdr m.s subbalakshmi's sakunthalai)

    kalki was particularly irritated with a rather sexy scene that
    occured. not much details are available except that a rat was
    involved in the scene.
    kalki termed the movie a insult to sekkilar, gopalakrishna barathi,
    and even the rat. he said if the rat was to see the movie it would
    commit suicide.
    venketesh
    .
  • -Hi kalki's review was for baktha nandanar produced in 1942


    actually nandanar was produced thrice in a decade. 1933, 1935, and
    in 1942- the last by vasan

    venketesh
  • the full story or is it...

    http://randorguy.galatta.com/blog/randorguy/Lakshmikantham-
    Murde/bdid/309.html

    November 8, 1944… Madras, a sea-kissed sunny city founded some 350
    plus years ago by an employee of the East India Company, Francis
    Day, the provincial capital woke up as usual as the resplendent sun
    rose
    out of the blue waters of the Bay of Bengal. To one of its
    citizens,named C. N. Lakshmikantham, a colorful character of
    considerable notoriety, a popular journalist of the 'yellow' variety
    it would be his last day on this planet. Only he was blissfully
    ignorant of it all. Indeed if someone had told him so that day-
    break he would have
    laughed it off, mixing it with some rich colorful two-letter Tamil
    words (the equivalent of the English four-lettered ones!) and most
    likely he would have slapped that bold someone! Such was the man,
    the
    earliest of yellow journalists, the prince of muck-rakers.

    After finishing his mundane morning chores this go-getter was on his
    way in a man drawn rickshaw to meet his lawyer an Indian Christian
    who looked more like a Shakespearean actor with his wavy hair, long
    side-burns and all named J. Nargunam. At that time he had only a
    modest practice and lived on Maddox Street, Vepery, not very far
    from where Lakshmikantham lived in a narrow house-lined street in
    nearby
    Purasawalkam. The client and lawyer were good friends and met
    almost every evening after court hours.

    Lakshmikantham was quite a court-bird. And a big of a jailbird too.
    Indeed his pre-journalist life reads like a chapter from a best
    selling suspense thriller. He had ambitions of becoming a lawyer,
    something he loved but he could not afford to go to Law College.
    Yet he did not forget it and read law books. He frequented law
    courts of Madras city and hobnobbed with small fry lawyers,
    briefless, breadless
    ones and litigants of the illiterate kind. Clever and quick-witted
    he soon became a law tout. Touts though prohibited by law are men
    who take cases and other legal matters to lawyers for a substantial
    'kick-back' in the fee. Patronised by briefless and struggling
    lawyers some touts in Madras with a smattering of legal knowledge
    earn more than most lawyers. They draft deeds and documents, wills
    and
    notices mostly for illiterates and some touts resort to forgery and
    fabricating documents very casually of course, for a stiff fee.

    Lakshmikantham was one such tout and smart enough to argue his own
    cases in court. One of his shady deals involving the fabrication of
    a sworn affidavit created by him in a case filed against him by a
    leading Madras daily found him in the dock in the Madras High Court
    Original Sessions. During the hearing he escaped hoodwinking a
    posse of cops and for a while he lived a happy-go-lucky life, until
    the cops
    nabbed and brought him to trial. Found guilty he received a 7 year
    jail sentence and was ordered to be imprisoned at Rajamundry, then
    in Madras presidency and now in Andhra Pradesh. While the train
    taking
    him was crossing a river in Andhra he, hand-chained, managed to
    escape fooling the guarding cops and jumped from the chug-chugging
    train into the river below shrouded by darkness. With chains and
    all he swam
    across the big river and disappeared into the dark night. He roamed
    around freely for a long while until an angry girl friend tipped off
    the searching Madras city cops. Back in custody he was declared
    a 'dangerous convict' and deported to the Andamans. With an ocean
    surrounding this famed island prison, Lakshmikantham could not even
    dream of escape. He served his term until as a war security measure
    he along with others was set fee and shipped back home.

    Back in Madras, a notorious ex-convict, he avoided courts and cops
    for whom he had an understandable allergy! Life had to go on and he
    dabbled in many things. He ran a small restaurant serving meat
    dishes
    which in south India were then known as "military hotels" {Eateries
    serving only vegetarian food were called 'civil' hotels}. He lost
    in this venture and looked around for greener pastures. Soon he
    found
    one, Journalism. A profession that would bring him money, fame or
    more precisely notoriety, and a violent end.

    Around 1943 he launched a film weekly in Tamil "Cinema Thoothu". It
    was a different kind of magazine. Lakshmikantham did not publish
    articles about theories and trends in cinema and such. He filled the
    pages with tales of bedroom activities, amours and amatory
    adventures of prominent filmland figures like reigning superstar M.
    K. Thyagaraja Bhagavathar, brilliant comedian hailed as the 'Charlie
    Chaplin of
    India', N. S. Krishnan and his star wife T. A. Mathuram, successful
    producer S. M. Sreeramulu Naidu and many others enjoying stardom and
    immense popularity in south India. He ran "series" about
    Bhagavathar and Krishnan as a weekly feature. He wielded a facile
    pen and his writing was lively, punchy and enjoyable to read.
    Bhagavathar, a singing star was then at his zenith of his career and
    fame. More a singer than an actor his following was incredible.
    Masses, classes, intellectuals, upper crust folks, all loved him,
    his music. Women
    adored him and many society dames threw themselves at him. Such was
    his charisma. At this time he was one of the most famous figures of
    south India, a household name.


    No wonder, "Cinema Thoothu", the first of its kind was a raving sell-
    out and copies sold at a premium. The Tamil-speaking world had
    never seen anything like this weekly. The south Indian society, some
    forty and odd years ago was conservative, old-fashioned and subjects
    like sex were strictly taboo and barely whispered. In such rigid,
    regimented atmosphere not surprisingly people loved gossip and
    scandal
    and hungered to read and know all about the goings-on behind closed
    doors in high places. Movie glamour had already seeped into the
    skin and soul of society and this wily pen-totter took a hundred-and-
    ten
    per cent advantage of it all.

    What was Lakshmikantham's aim in running such a magazine? He
    professed, at least in public to be a traditionalist with a
    missionary zeal to uphold the ideals and high values of ancient
    Indian culture.
    He claimed he was socially conscious reformer come to earth, to
    clean the stables free of sinners and seducers, adulterers and the
    likes. But his real aim,
  • Superb vijay

    Truth is certainly stranger than fiction
  • coming to think of it ( thanks to a chat session with divakar
    sir)...we can draw a lot of parrallels to PS from this even!!!

    - a slightly hot headed guy getted bumped off ( aplogies to all AK
    fans for the comparison)
    - a mystery women involved
    - doubts cast on a lot of people
    - a gang being used for the act
    - a murder weapon ( knife)
    - a prev murder could be assigned a cause ( the boat mail case
    disclosure - the beheading of pandyan...can we call it murder - ok
    he was hurt, without any arms - so could call it murder)
    - a witness ( the rickshaw puller) though being present not able to
    be called as an eye witness ( VT??)
    - wrongly accused ( VT) in prime of his youth and
    imprisoned...upcoming star!!!
    - witnesses turning hostile
    - then prime accused being set free

    if we extrapolate to nandipurathu nayagi - a letter being used as a
    evidence....

    wow, we can see PS in everything seems

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Top Posters