PS: Turning - point?
  • Dear all...


    PS has a lot of turning points:-) but I think it all really starts
    with VD listening into the 'sathitittam'. There, the events start
    escalating at break-neck pace. So that's the real 'turning-point', in
    my opinion.:-)

    Imagine what might have happened if VD had decided to ignore that
    midnight meeting, and go his sweet way, come hell or high-water:-)

    AK's murder comes at the end of PS. Would that qualify as an
    ideal 'turning-point'?
  • >PS has a lot of turning points:-) but I think it all really starts
    >with VD listening into the 'sathitittam'. There, the events start
    >escalating at break-neck pace. So that's the real 'turning-point', in
    >my opinion.:-)

    idhai naan vazhi mozhikirEn.

    >Cheers,
    >Pavithra.
  • Dear Sri,

    In single mail you are achieving !

    After "Krupa's Wedding?!" - there are again activities now. Nice..

    Two view points have surfaced so far :

    1. VD's night stay at Kadambur & listening to Sadhialosanai.
    2. AK's Murder

    Strictly speaking I read & re-read PS several years back. I remember
    the story as a whole - but not event by event.

    VD is sent from Kanchi by AK to assess Thanjavur events. He takes the
    route of Viluppuram (Thirukkovilur via) - Sethiathope -
    Veeranarayanapuram (Veeranam) - Kadambur. Sambuvarayar's son Kandhan
    Maran requests him to stay that night thinking VD may qualify for his
    sister Manimekalai. He fumbles on this gathering : Pazhuvettarayars -
    Madurantakan (bad) - Sambuvarayars & co., By the end there is a
    Kuralan yelling there is going to be a loss to the Throne.

    I did not consider this as a turning point because AK already
    suspected the involvement of those assembled in Kadambur. If one
    recalls -AK is the only affected person because there was an uprise
    against him - who was already an Yuvaraja (Crown Prince).

    Those assembled there did not want him to become the King when
    Sundara dies.Instead they wanted Maduranataka to become a puppet
    King. (What a lovely story .. the land offerings to Ravidasan & co
    by Madurantaka subsequently proves this line of thinking very well)

    These people did not air their views when AK was made the Yuvaraja in
    the presence of Sembianmadei - ignoring Madurantaka - by Sundara
    Chola. But Siriyapazhuvettarayar had the foresight and gave his
    daughter in wedding to Maduranatakan. (All supported by Historical
    facts)

    Pazhuvettarayars could not sit tight but to instal Madurantakan.

    AK was the only obstruction to all of them assembled over there.

    The only agenda was to design getting rid of him.

    This is the KNOT for the Story.

    (HAD ANYBODY ANTICIPATED IN THE GATHERING THAT ARUNMOZHI WOULD EMERGE
    AS CHAKRAVARTHY RAJARAJA ONE DAY, THEY WOULD HAVE ELIMINATED HIM
    ALSO. HOW CLEVER ARUNMOZHI WAS .. EXACTLY KUNDAVAI FEAR THIS AGAIN &
    AGAIN.. KALKI HAS RANSACKED CHOLA HISTORY AND DEVELOPED THE STORY
    LINE.. I AM SURE HE WOULD HAVE DISCUSSED IT WITH SASTRY & PANDARATHAR
    & OTHERS SEVERAL TIMES )

    Aditya's murder - Madurantaka's ascendency - Ravidasan's role in AK's
    murder - is the story of Ponniyinselvan.

    Arunmozhi finding this and becoming Rajaraja ...A story yet to be
    told..

    VD's experience was only a reinforcement to AK's suspecion..

    Hence I did not consider this as a turning point..

    ADITHA KARIKALAN'S MURDER WAS THE TRUE TURNING POINT OF NOT ONLY
    CHOLA HISTORY BUT ALSO SOUTH INDIA HISTORY ...

    Fondly, SB
  • Hello All,

    VD's night stay at Kadambur & listening to
    Sadhialosanai - Yes this is the turning point.

    We are talking about the turning point in the story of
    Ponniyinselvan.

    AK's murder is at the fag end of the story, it can not
    be a turning point.

    If it is the history of Cholas or of South India as SB
    says, yes the turning point is the murder of AK.

    Are there any other views - apart from these two
    points?

    Looking forward to see different views,
  • The turning point in the story is AK's Murder...

    Because, this brought about the end of a long winding story.....kadhaiya eppadi mudikkaradhunnu theriyaamal kalki thindadikinu irundhiruppaar..... AK's murder proved very useful in this context.

    So Ak's murder is the turning point

    with luv
    B.Dhiwakar
  • Hi Guys,
    I have been reading all ur mails since last month..
    and really enjoyed a lot.

    I reckon, AK killing VEERAPANDIYAN was the absolute
    turning point.

    Please do post ur comments

    Thank You
  • Diwa

    as for as the story is concerned AKs murder is a certainity because
    it is history and kalki didnt write that he jus used it in his
    storyline bacuse all the readers knew he ll be dead the question was
    when and how


    Sri

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Top Posters